

2024 – Emilia Perez
Ok, what the heck did I just watch? This movie was strange, bordering on bizarre. It was certainly unique in a very artistic way. And knowing next to nothing about it when I sat down to watch, it surprised me in a good way. It was a musical… kind of. It was a drama… mostly. It was a suspense thriller… but not really. Wikipedia calls it a Spanish-Language French musical crime film, though I would call it a drama, as well.
It had a relatively small main cast which included Zoe Saldana, Karla Sofia Gascon, Selena Gomez, Adriana Paz, Edgar Ramirez, and Mark Ivanir. They all did a very good job, though the movie was really about Saldana’s character, Rita Mora Castro. The story begins with her and ends with her, and follows her journey from start to finish, though she won the Oscar for the Best Supporting Actress category. She is a lawyer in Mexico who is disillusioned with her job defending criminals. She is recruited by drug cartel crime boss Manitas Del Monte, but for a job that was as surprising to me as it was to her. He wants to undergo gender reassignment surgery, leaving his wife, his sons, and his life of crime behind him.
Rita accepts the job for a massive amount of money and finds Manitas a surgeon, relocates his family to Switzerland, tells them Manitas has been killed, and then disappears with her payment. The drama comes when a woman, now called Emilia Perez, finds her and recruits her once again to bring his/her family to Mexico City because she misses her children.
It was a strange concept for a plot, but what made the movie exponentially stranger was that it was a musical. I have a friend who doesn’t care for musicals because he can’t get past the idea that people in a perfectly normal story would, for no apparent reason, start to sing and dance, and then, when a song is over, just go back to regular acting, and all the while, pretending that nothing out of the ordinary just happened. This movie would have driven him crazy because the music was sly in the way it infiltrated the narrative. Someone would be talking, just ordinary dialogue, when suddenly I would realize that they were talking in rhythm. A percussion beat would creep in beneath them, and without realizing it, I would be listening to a song. Then, the extras in the background would start to dance in highly choreographed sequences that were wonderfully executed.
There was a scene near the end of the movie where Rita is bringing in a team of rough banditos with some major firearms to rescue Emilia, who has been abducted and is being tortured. There is a dramatic underscore as the men are preparing their weapons for the mission. But then, unexpectedly, I noticed that the men were moving in unison, the clicking of their guns as they are being loaded and readied for combat, became part of the music. It was almost subtle in how it slipped in under the radar.
The cast did a great job, but I really have to mention Karla Sofia Gascon. The first time she is on the screen, I totally believed she was a man. The makeup department outdid themselves. As the cartel kingpin, she/he looked scary and intimidating, even as he was telling Rita that he wanted to be a woman, and not because he wanted to go into hiding, but because he’d wanted to be a woman since childhood. But as I think about it, those few scenes were darkly lit, helping to hide the illusion. Also, even while watching the movie, I was wondering why Manitas spoke and sang without moving his lips. I thought it was a character choice, but I think maybe it was also to help hide the fact that the female actress was made up as a different gender. Honestly, I bought the illusion, hook, line, and sinker.
Selena Gomez, playing Manitas’s wife, Jessi, also did a great job. Once she was dropped off in Switzerland, I thought I’d seen the last of her, but when she was brought back in later, she created a realistic character with some depth and a relatable arch. She feels manipulated and bound to the will of her dead husband as a sister-in-law she has never met suddenly begins to steal her children from her. The climactic scene, where Emilia is near death, she comes clean and tells her who she actually used to be. Jessi, who is part of the team who has tortured Emilia, is still in love with the husband she had thought dead, and she has one of those classic “What have I done?” moments. Gomez did a great job!
But of course, I think the stand-out of the cast was Saldana. She did it all. She handled the singing, the dancing, and the drama perfectly. I loved the scene where Emilia reveals herself to Rita in London. That look of shock and fear in Rita’s face was perfect as she connected the dots and realized who she was talking to. And who knew Saldana could sing and dance like that? She really did a fantastic job. But again, I think she was really the main character, not Emilia.
This movie surprised me in several ways, and I think director Jaques Audiard really did some things that were bold, unique, and ultimately fascinating to watch. The unconventional story, and the way in which it was told, was captivating on the screen. It was visually interesting, and the soundtrack was unexpected. I also have to give a big thumbs up to the choreographer, Damien Jalet. But all that being said, I don’t really understand why there are so many critics of the film. Mexico criticized it on a cultural level, the LGBTQ community did so in defense of trans-people, and both critics and audiences called the film insensitive to drug traffickers. People just seem too eager to be offended. Just relax and enjoy the movie. I see it as a unique piece of art, and one that I wouldn’t mind watching again.